| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| National | ||||||||
| Softball | ||||||||
| 2011-2012 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position | |||||
| Mary Wiley | Old Tappan | Junior | First Base | |||||
| Alyssa Incantalupo | Ramapo | Sophomore | Infield | |||||
| Caitlyn Hickey | Ramapo | Junior | Infield | |||||
| Kayla Farrell | Old Tappan | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Taylor Summers | Northern Nighlands | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Mindy Gorin | Northern Highlands | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Alexa Smedberg | Old Tappan | Freshman | Outfield | |||||
| Allison Brown | Old Tappan | Senior | Catcher | |||||
| Alexis Bush | Fair Lawn | Select Grade | Catcher | |||||
| Marissa Spinuzzi | Fair Lawn | Junior | Pitcher | |||||
| Kristen Farrell | Old Tappan | Freshman | Pitcher | |||||
| Katie Duncan | Northern Highlands | Freshman | Pitcher | |||||
| Sasha Brown | Northern Highlands | Sophomore | At Large | |||||
| Lexi Graber | Ramapo | Junior | At Large | |||||
| JK McAvoy | Ramapo | Junior | At Large | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position | |||||
| Emili | Northern Highlands | Junior | First Base | |||||
| Jennifer Calabrese | Fair Lawn | Junior | Infield | |||||
| Melanie Psota | Ramapo | Sophomore | Infield | |||||
| Sabrina Capabianca | Old Tappan | Junior | Infield | |||||
| Katie Neglia | Old Tappan | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Megan O’Donnell | Northern Highlands | Freshman | Outfield | |||||
| Brittany Meerholz | Fair Lawn | Freshman | Outfield | |||||
| Gabby Garcia | Demarest | Junior | Catcher | |||||
| Sophie Nochta | Ramapo | Junior | Pitcher | |||||
| Emma Nelson | Old Tappan | Freshman | At Large | |||||
| Allison Mueller | Ramapo | Junior | At Large | |||||
| Samantha Colca | Fair Lawn | Sophomore | At Large | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | ||||||
| Samantha Szura | Ramapo | Junior | ||||||
| Christina Carbaugh | Old Tappan | Senior | ||||||
| Danielle Semsey | Demarest | Senior | ||||||
| Kasey Dunbar | Northern Highlands | Senior | ||||||
| Ashley Sudol | Fair Lawn | Junior | ||||||
| Coach of the year | David Sachs | |||||||
| School | Northern Highlands | |||||||
